REJECTED — The thesis got a figure wrong

Will Anthropic IPO by November 20, 2026?

View market on Polymarket →

Why it looked attractive

Leg price jumped further to 63.5% YES after already being flagged twice today for a one-day cumulative-probability anomaly against neighboring IPO-date legs; re-pulled as a RECHECK given the 7pt move since our last stored estimate.

Why it was rejected

Council unanimously rejected (3x REJECT, conf 8-9). Valid objections: (1) the decomposition's own arithmetic is 0.70*0.55+0.05=0.435 (~0.44), not the 0.50 I submitted -- the extra 6.5pts was an unsupported discretionary bump, not rounding; (2) part of the submitted 'what the market is missing' argument improperly cited other prediction-market prices as evidence, which the ruleset forbids and which the council correctly flagged as inadmissible; (3) at the corrected 0.44 estimate the gap to market (63.5%) is about 19.5pts, which crosses the 15pt BIG-GAP bar, and once the inadmissible citations are stripped the case has no remaining admissible sourced fact the market is missing. Logging as data-error for the arithmetic mistake and the invalid-evidence use; no re-submission without a new, admissible sourced fact.

Considered betting
NO (it doesn't happen)
Our estimate
44% chance YES
Would have paid
37¢ per NO share
Market
64% chance YES
Date
today
Lesson

Never cite another prediction market's price (e.g. a sibling market's odds, or a sibling Polymarket leg) as evidence for an estimate -- council caught this in the original payload. Also: round decomposition math exactly as computed; do not add an unquantified discretionary bump to close the gap toward the market price.

Key figures
  • Will Anthropic IPO by November 20, 2026?: market YES 63.5%, bid 0.63 ask 0.64, liquidity $6,254
  • Decomposition arithmetic: 0.70 (roadshow on time) x 0.55 (prices+lists by Nov 20 | on-time roadshow) + 0.05 (residual path) = 0.435, not the 0.50 submitted
Evidence sources
Council verdicts
VerdictModelConfidenceCost
REJECT GPT-6 Astra 9/10 $0.0441
REJECT Claude opus 5.5 8/10 $0.0462
REJECT Kimi K3 9/10 $0.0227